[方法探讨] 求文献：中国孩子几岁开始适合接触外语？

非英语国家，母语非英语的孩子，几岁适合开始接触英语？

本来想做辩论的，但闹哄哄的没意思。

希望回帖的朋友给出文献或科学网页链接，不要谈自己或身边的例子。

1798 查看 14 收藏帖子 (0)

说说我的看法高级模式

全部评论

sandydad

2013-3-26 18:21:25 使用道具

FINDINGS CONFIRM BENEFITS OF EARLY ENGLISH LEARNING

laoxu520

2013-3-26 19:05:17 使用道具

不信疗效，信广告。

tempax

2013-3-26 19:08:26 使用道具

本帖最后由 tempax 于 2013-3-26 19:13 编辑

帮你指2条道吧:
1. 直接问专家
2. 自己GOOGLE或者BAIDU.

圣圆居士

2013-3-26 20:18:25 使用道具

没有可比性！家庭教育方式生活环境的差别会直接影响

lmjcle

2013-3-26 20:22:39 使用道具

本帖最后由 lmjcle 于 2013-3-26 20:24 编辑

http://www.ebama.net/thread-131263-1-1.html

那我就很不客气的推销一下自己的旧贴了，看过的筒子不必去了，就是关于关键期那个，里面有提到二语的实验。
不算直接回答，但可以作辅证，能形成证据链。

93776940

2013-3-26 23:59:18 使用道具

这个看过很多文章，都没留存，很多是综述归纳性的，至于有没有文献，印象可能是有部分借助了一些研究报告。
在我印象里面，是12岁前，6岁后，这个是比较肯定的。
也有部分提前到3-6岁。
但是0-3岁的大概是爸妈网比较普遍存在的。在资料里面（除掉那些学习机构狗皮膏药式的信口开河表述以外），我对这个年龄段学习外语并没有很深刻的印象。

对了，楼主家的娃多大了？多一事不如少一事，呵呵。如果要辩论，我支持，到时候凑巧，也去赶赶场，混个露脸。

high5

2013-3-27 01:46:49 使用道具

second language acquisition: the age factor
http://www.wce.wwu.edu/Resources/CIRCLE/Lectures/SarahJuliaAge_SLAcomments%20(2).pdf

Age, rate and eventual attainment in second language acquisition

The study of second language acquisition

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN AGE AND SECOND LANGUAGE PRODUCTIVE ABILITY
论文概要：

This study examines the relationship between certain aspects of the second language acquisition process and age. An oral production test was developed to assess the ability of nonnative English speaking children to produce standard English morphology and syntax. The test was administered to approximately 200 children (ages 6–15) who were learning English as a second language in American public schools. The results of this testing were used to examine the relationship between age and 1) the rate of acquisition of certain English grammatical structures and 2) the order of acquisition of these grammatical structures.

The results indicated that there was some relationship between age and rate of learning. Among children exposed to English the same amounts of time, the older children scored higher on the morphology and syntax subtests, whereas the younger children received higher ratings in phonology. There were, however, no major differences observed in the order in which children of different ages learned to produce the structures included in the test. These results suggest that there is a difference in the rate of learning of English morphology, syntax and phonology based upon differences in age, but that the order of acquisition in second language learning does not change with age.

------------------------------------

国内应该有论文库，需要付费进入。

国外可以搜索google Scholar. 里面有专著和论文等文献。有的是可以看到全文，有的仅有概要。

国外研究，注重于外语学习的不多，多是第二语言学习的研究（这在其本国更是当务之急）。不管是外语还是二语，又多集中在英语，法语，德语，西班牙语这几种语言之间的学习。比如说，英语是母语者，去学习西语或是法语或德语。和我们中文为母语的，去学英语会有很大的不同。所以，更希望看到：

中文为母语，去学英语的文献和实践

英文为母语，去学中文的文献或是实践